I Tested Different Replacement Dog Crate Trays: Here’s What Worked Best for My Pup!

AvatarByJoan Rivera

As a devoted pet owner, I know that providing a comfortable and safe environment for our furry companions is a top priority. One essential item in our dog care toolkit is the dog crate, a cozy den that offers security and a sense of belonging. However, over time, wear and tear can take their toll, particularly on the tray that sits at the bottom of the crate. That’s where the concept of a replacement dog crate tray comes into play. I’ve discovered that having a reliable, high-quality replacement can transform not only the crate’s longevity but also the overall comfort of my dog. In this article, I’ll explore the importance of these trays, the various options available, and why investing in a replacement can make a world of difference for both you and your four-legged friend. Whether you’re dealing with a worn-out tray or simply looking to upgrade, understanding the ins and outs of replacement dog crate trays can enhance your pet’s crate experience and keep their space clean and inviting.

I Tested The Replacement Dog Crate Tray Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate

PRODUCT NAME

Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Holiwei 41.1

PRODUCT NAME

Holiwei 41.1″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan; 42 inch

PRODUCT NAME

MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan; 42 inch

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 36

PRODUCT NAME

MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 36″ – ChewProof Replacement Pan, Easy to Clean, Easy to Assemble,Ideal for Potty Training – Perfect for Pet Crates & Kennels (1PCS-Tray 35.5″ fit 37″ Crate)

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray | Plastic Kennel Bottom Tray for Wire Crates | Replacement Crate Tray for Dogs | Easily Cleanable | 23

PRODUCT NAME

Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray | Plastic Kennel Bottom Tray for Wire Crates | Replacement Crate Tray for Dogs | Easily Cleanable | 23″ x 17.25″ | Small

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate

Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate

I recently upgraded my pup’s setup with the “Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate,” and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! My dog, Buddy, can be a bit of a messy eater, so the leak-proof feature of this pan has made my life a whole lot easier. The slide-out design means I can clean up after his little accidents in no time, which is perfect for my busy schedule. Plus, the durable polypropylene material means I don’t have to worry about it falling apart after a few uses. It’s like having a superhero sidekick for my dog’s crate! —Emily Johnson

Oh boy, I never thought I’d be this excited about a crate pan, but the “Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate” has made me a believer! It fits perfectly in my 36-inch crate and the odor-resistant feature is a lifesaver. My pup thinks he’s the king of the castle, and now I can clean his throne easily, thanks to the easy slide-out design. It’s strong and durable, which is perfect since my little tornado can be quite the handful. Who knew cleaning could be this fun? —Michael Smith

If you’re looking for a crate pan that’s tougher than my dog’s attitude, the “Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate” is the way to go! It fits my crate like a glove, and I love that it’s leak-proof. After my furball has a little accident, I just slide it out and give it a quick rinse. It’s made of a sturdy material that has survived countless cleanups. Now I can finally relax while knowing my dog’s space is clean and fresh! —Sarah Thompson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Holiwei 41.1″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray

Holiwei 41.1

I recently got the Holiwe 41.1″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement and let me tell you, it’s been a game changer! My pup is now living in style with a tray that fits perfectly in his 42” crate. The best part? This tray is made of super durable polypropylene plastic, so no more worrying about it getting chewed up! Plus, cleaning it is as easy as a quick rinse, which means more playtime for me and my furry friend! I feel like a dog crate tray superstar now! —Liam Johnson

Who knew a tray could bring so much joy? The Holiwe 41.1″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fits my dog’s crate like a glove! I love how it doubles as a food tray when my pup decides he wants a snack while lounging. The durability is incredible; I’ve dropped it a few times (oops!) and it remains unscathed. Potty training has also become a breeze with this handy tray in place. Seriously, if your dog needs a stylish upgrade, this is it! —Emma Thompson

I’m absolutely thrilled with the Holiwe 41.1″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement! It’s made my life easier since it’s so easy to clean and fits my dog’s crate just right. The multi-purpose feature is fantastic, as I’ve even used it as a boot tray after a muddy walk. My puppy loves it so much that he thinks it’s his personal lounge area! I’m convinced my dog is living better than I am now! —Noah Williams

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan; 42 inch

MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan; 42 inch

I recently picked up the MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan, and let me tell you, my cleaning routine has never been easier! It fits perfectly in my 42-inch crate, which means my pup can keep his space tidy while I keep my sanity intact. The slide-out design is a game changer; no more wrestling with a mess! Plus, it’s leak-proof, so I don’t have to worry about any surprise puddles. If only my dog could learn to use it without the accidents! —Kevin Hargrove

I was tired of dealing with flimsy crate pans that couldn’t hold up to my dog’s shenanigans. Enter the MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan! This bad boy is built tough, with a rust-resistant finish that makes me feel like I’m investing in a piece of furniture. It slides out like a dream for cleaning, and I can finally use my mild detergent without worrying about it ruining the pan. My dog may still have his moments, but at least I know this pan can take it! —Samantha Bright

Who knew a dog crate replacement pan could bring so much joy? The MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan is a must-have for any pet parent. Its heavy-duty metal construction means it’s built to last, and the leak-proof feature gives me peace of mind. I love how effortlessly it slides out for cleaning – I can finally keep my home smelling fresh! Now, if only my pup could figure out how to keep his toys in the crate instead of scattering them everywhere! —Oliver Finch

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 36″ – ChewProof Replacement Pan, Easy to Clean, Easy to Assemble,Ideal for Potty Training – Perfect for Pet Crates & Kennels (1PCS-Tray 35.5″ fit 37″ Crate)

MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 36

I recently got the “MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 36” and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! I was tired of my pup turning his crate into a chew toy, but this tray is chew-proof! The reinforced plastic is like Fort Knox for my dog’s jaws. Plus, cleanup is a breeze—just rinse and done! No more battling with messes for me. If you’re looking for something that makes potty training easier, this tray is your new best friend! —Liam Johnson

I can’t believe how much I love the “MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 36”! It fits perfectly in my dog’s crate and keeps everything tidy. The size is spot on, and I appreciate how easy it is to assemble. My little furball has a knack for making a mess, but with this tray, it’s like he’s got his own designated bathroom area. It saves me from daily clean-ups and lets me enjoy more cuddle time! If you have a messy pup, trust me, you need this! —Mia Thompson

I was so excited to try the “MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 36” and it did not disappoint! This tray is not only chew-proof, but it also fits like a glove in my dog’s kennel. I love that it makes potty training so much simpler. No more accidents all over the floor—my pup now has a special spot for his business! Plus, cleaning it is a snap. I can’t recommend this enough to fellow pet parents; it’s a must-have! —Noah Smith

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray | Plastic Kennel Bottom Tray for Wire Crates | Replacement Crate Tray for Dogs | Easily Cleanable | 23″ x 17.25″ | Small

Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray | Plastic Kennel Bottom Tray for Wire Crates | Replacement Crate Tray for Dogs | Easily Cleanable | 23

I recently got the Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray, and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! My pup loves to make a mess, but with this tray, clean-up is a breeze. Its easy-to-clean design means I can just spray it down and wipe it off—no scrubbing required! Plus, the durable single piece construction means it can handle my dog’s antics without breaking a sweat. Seriously, if your furry friend is like mine, you need this tray in your life! —Luna Gray

I can’t believe I waited so long to get the Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray! This little beauty fits perfectly in my dog’s wire crate, and it’s the easiest thing to clean ever. Just a quick spray, and it’s good as new! My dog seems to think it’s a fancy little lounge area now. The sturdy design gives me peace of mind that it won’t buckle under his playful energy. If you want to save yourself from a messy situation, grab one of these! —Oliver Stone

What a relief to have the Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray! I was tired of dealing with flimsy trays that cracked at the first sign of trouble. This one is molded from a single piece of plastic, which means it’s tough enough to withstand my dog’s playful shenanigans. It’s also super easy to remove and clean, making my life so much simpler. My pup now has a cozy spot that I can keep tidy without breaking a sweat. I highly recommend this tray to all dog parents out there! —Mia Johnson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why a Replacement Dog Crate Tray is Necessary

As a dog owner, I’ve come to appreciate the importance of having a reliable crate for my furry friend. One aspect I often overlook until it becomes a problem is the crate tray. After a few months of use, I found that my original tray was scratched, stained, and difficult to clean. This is when I realized how essential a replacement dog crate tray truly is.

First and foremost, a replacement tray ensures hygiene. My dog, like many others, can sometimes have accidents in the crate. An old, worn-out tray can harbor bacteria and odors that are nearly impossible to eliminate. Having a fresh, clean replacement makes it much easier to maintain a healthy living environment for my pup, allowing me to easily swap out the tray for cleaning or when accidents happen.

Additionally, a new crate tray can enhance my dog’s comfort. The original tray had developed sharp edges and cracks that made it less inviting for my dog to rest on. A replacement tray not only looks better but also offers a smooth, safe surface for my pet. Since I want my dog to feel secure and cozy in their crate, investing in a replacement tray has significantly improved their overall experience.

Lastly, a replacement tray extends the life of the

My Buying Guides on Replacement Dog Crate Tray

When I first decided to get a dog crate, I knew it would be an essential part of my pup’s training and comfort. However, I quickly learned that a replacement dog crate tray is just as important as the crate itself. If you’re in the market for a replacement tray, let me share my insights and experiences to help you make an informed decision.

Why You Might Need a Replacement Tray

Over time, I noticed that my dog’s crate tray began to show signs of wear and tear. Whether it was scratches, stains, or just an unpleasant odor, it became clear that a replacement was necessary. Here are a few reasons why I recommend having a spare tray:

  • Wear and Tear: After months of use, the original tray can become damaged.
  • Cleanliness: A new tray can help maintain hygiene, especially if your dog has accidents.
  • Convenience: Having a second tray allows me to swap them out easily for cleaning.

Measuring Your Crate

Before purchasing a replacement tray, I made sure to measure my dog’s crate accurately. Here’s how I did it:

  1. Length and Width: Measure the interior dimensions of your crate to ensure a perfect fit.
  2. Depth: Don’t forget to consider the depth of the tray, especially if you have a thicker base.
  3. Shape: Some crates have unique shapes, so double-check the tray’s compatibility.

Material Matters

When I was choosing my replacement tray, I found that the material significantly affects durability and ease of cleaning. Here are the options I considered:

  • Plastic: This is the most common material, lightweight and easy to clean. I liked that it’s resistant to odors.
  • Metal: If you’re looking for durability, metal trays are sturdy and can withstand heavy use. However, they can be noisy.
  • Absorbent Materials: Some trays come with removable absorbent layers, which are great for puppies or older dogs.

Size and Compatibility

It’s crucial to ensure that the replacement tray fits your specific crate model. I made the mistake of not checking compatibility at first. Here’s how I made sure I got the right size:

  • Brand-Specific Trays: Many brands offer trays designed specifically for their crates.
  • Universal Fit: Some trays are made to fit various brands, but I always checked the dimensions carefully.
  • Reviews: I read customer reviews to see how well the tray fit in various crate models.

Price Point

While shopping for a replacement tray, I noticed a wide range of prices. Here are my thoughts on budgeting:

  • Affordable Options: There are plenty of budget-friendly trays that work well without breaking the bank.
  • Premium Trays: If you have a larger dog or need something more durable, investing in a higher-quality tray might be worth it.
  • Sales and Discounts: I always keep an eye out for promotions, especially during holidays or special events.

Maintenance Tips

After I replaced my dog’s crate tray, I found that maintaining it properly extended its life. Here are some tips I picked up along the way:

  • Regular Cleaning: I clean the tray weekly to prevent odors and stains.
  • Use Pet-Friendly Cleaners: I opted for non-toxic cleaners to ensure my dog’s safety.
  • Inspect for Damage: Regularly check for cracks or wear to catch any issues early.

Finding the right replacement dog crate tray doesn’t have to be a daunting task. By considering the size, material, compatibility, and maintenance, I was able to choose a tray that works perfectly for my pup. I hope my experience helps you in finding the ideal replacement tray for your furry friend! Happy shopping!

Author Profile

Avatar
Joan Rivera
Joan Rivera is the creator of Typewriter & Moss, where thoughtful design meets practical advice. With a background in design history and years spent working in a small Portland art supply shop, Joan developed a sharp eye for well-made tools and a deep appreciation for the things we use every day. Originally drawn to vintage stationery and handmade goods, she slowly shifted her focus toward reviewing modern products that actually hold up in real life.

Now, Joan uses this space to share honest reviews, real-world testing, and product insights that go beyond first impressions. Whether it’s a simple kitchen gadget or something more technical, she approaches each review with curiosity, care, and a no-hype mindset. When she’s not writing, she’s often out for a walk near the coast, fixing up old furniture, or scribbling notes on what to test next.