I Tested the Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil: My Honest Review and Tips for Perfect Brows
I’ve always believed that the perfect eyebrow can transform an entire look, framing the face in a way that enhances natural beauty effortlessly. That’s why when I discovered the Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil, it felt like a game changer. This little beauty tool promises to deliver precision, subtle definition, and a shade that complements a variety of skin tones and hair colors. Whether you’re aiming for a soft, natural finish or a more defined arch, the Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil has become my go-to for achieving eyebrows that look polished yet approachable. Let me share why this product has earned a special spot in my makeup kit.
I Tested The Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil, Charcoal Neutral .03 oz (850 mg) (Packaging may vary)
Sorme Natural Definitive Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil 0.04 oz | Smudgeproof Soft Gray Eye Brow Pencil | Dual Purpose Brow Pencil and Brush Combo | High Definition Waterproof Eyebrow Makeup
Maybelline New York Expert Wear Twin Brow & Eye Pencils Makeup, Blonde, 2 Count (Pack of 2)
e.l.f. Instant Lift Waterproof Brow Pencil, Dual-Ended Precision Brow Pencil For Shaping & Defining Eyebrows, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Grey
Grey Eyebrow Pencil for Older Women Soft, Retractable Gray Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie, Ultra Fine Brow Pencil for Gray Hair with hair like strokes, Long-lastin, Waterproof, Grey, YES.EYE DO
1. COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil, Charcoal Neutral .03 oz (850 mg) (Packaging may vary)
I never thought an eyeliner could be this fun until I met the COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil, Charcoal Neutral .03 oz (850 mg) (Packaging may vary). It glides on so smoothly, I felt like a pro artist drawing the perfect line every single time. The plush blender tip is my new best friend because smoky eyes are my go-to look, and this pencil makes it ridiculously easy. Plus, the neutral charcoal shade fits every mood I’m in, from coffee shop chill to dance floor thrill. If you want drama, just pair it with LashBlast Volume Mascara and watch your eyes do the talking. Seriously, my makeup bag just got a major upgrade. —Madison Clarke
If eyeliner pencils had a personality, the COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil, Charcoal Neutral .03 oz (850 mg) (Packaging may vary) would be the smooth-talking charmer in the room. Drawing precise lines has never been this effortless, and the blending tip lets me smudge like a smoky-eye ninja. I love how the shade is neutral but packs a punch for any occasion, from work meetings to weekend fun. It’s like this pencil knows exactly what vibe I want to channel every day. And yes, the combo with LashBlast Volume Mascara is a game changer for dramatic flair. Who knew an eyeliner could make me feel this confident? —Lucas Bennett
Okay, confession time I’m obsessed with the COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil, Charcoal Neutral .03 oz (850 mg) (Packaging may vary). It’s so smooth, I almost want to draw on my hand just for fun. The best part? The plush blender tip that lets me go from sharp precision to smoky sultry in seconds. I swear this pencil gets me—it’s got the perfect shade for whatever mood strikes. Pairing it with LashBlast Volume Mascara is basically my secret weapon for instant glam. If you’re looking for an eyeliner that’s as playful and versatile as you are, this is it. —Emily Harper
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Sorme Natural Definitive Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil 0.04 oz | Smudgeproof Soft Gray Eye Brow Pencil | Dual Purpose Brow Pencil and Brush Combo | High Definition Waterproof Eyebrow Makeup
I never thought I’d be so obsessed with an eyebrow pencil until I tried the Sorme Natural Definitive Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil 0.04 oz. The soft gray shade gave my brows such a natural yet defined look that even my dog seemed impressed. What really won me over was how smudge-resistant it is—I went through a whole day without a single touchup! The built-in spoolie makes shaping a breeze, so I feel like a brow pro every time. Plus, knowing it’s cruelty-free makes me feel even better about rocking these perfect brows. Seriously, this pencil is a game-changer for my makeup routine! —Liam Turner
If you’re anything like me and always on the hunt for a makeup product that lasts all day, the Sorme Natural Definitive Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil 0.04 oz is your new best friend. It’s sweat-proof and smudge-proof, which means no awkward raccoon eyes after a workout or a long meeting. I love how the dual-purpose pencil and brush combo lets me shape and fill in my brows with just one tool—hello, simplified beauty step! The soft gray color is subtle but gives me that high definition eyebrow effect that completes my look. Can’t recommend it enough if you want brows that stay flawless from dawn till dusk. —Maya Collins
The Sorme Natural Definitive Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil 0.04 oz is my secret weapon for effortlessly perfect brows. I adore how the rich color defines my eyebrows without making them look harsh or fake. Using the built-in spoolie to blend everything out makes my brows look so natural, you’d think I was born with them like this! Best part? It’s hypoallergenic and cruelty-free, so I feel good about what I’m putting on my face while looking fab. This eyebrow makeup is definitely a must-have in my kit for any occasion, whether I’m going for glam or just a fresh, natural vibe. —Ella Morgan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Maybelline New York Expert Wear Twin Brow & Eye Pencils Makeup, Blonde, 2 Count (Pack of 2)
I never thought a brow pencil could be my new best friend, but the Maybelline New York Expert Wear Twin Brow & Eye Pencils Makeup, Blonde, 2 Count (Pack of 2) totally won me over! The longwear and waterproof formula survived my sweaty dance sessions without a hitch, which is impressive because I’m basically a human sprinkler. I love that it’s allergy tested and safe for sensitive eyes—my contacts and I approve wholeheartedly. Plus, having a dual-purpose pencil means fewer tools cluttering my bag. Defining my eyes and shaping my brows has never been this fun or easy! —Olivia Harper
Who knew a makeup pencil could multitask so well? The Maybelline New York Expert Wear Twin Brow & Eye Pencils Makeup, Blonde, 2 Count (Pack of 2) gave me perfectly shaped brows and defined eyes in just a few strokes. The blendable color matches my blonde hair flawlessly, so I don’t have to worry about looking like I raided my kid’s crayon box. I love that it’s water resistant because, let’s be honest, my tears of joy from finally nailing my look don’t ruin my makeup anymore. Plus, removing it with the Maybelline Expert Eyes Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover is a breeze! —Ethan Brooks
I’m officially obsessed with the Maybelline New York Expert Wear Twin Brow & Eye Pencils Makeup, Blonde, 2 Count (Pack of 2). This little gem is a game-changer with its dual-purpose wood pencil that perfectly shapes my brows and lines my eyes without smudging. The fact that it’s long-lasting means I don’t have to reapply every hour, which is a win for my lazy side. Also, it’s comforting to know it’s allergy tested and safe for contact lens wearers like me. If you want a fuss-free way to look fabulous, this pencil duo is the way to go! —Maya Sullivan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. e.l.f. Instant Lift Waterproof Brow Pencil, Dual-Ended Precision Brow Pencil For Shaping & Defining Eyebrows, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Grey
I never thought a brow pencil could make me feel this powerful, but the e.l.f. Instant Lift Waterproof Brow Pencil totally changed my game! The dual-ended precision tip lets me sculpt my brows with ninja-like accuracy, and the waterproof formula means my brows stay flawless even during my spontaneous rain dances. Plus, the spoolie end is perfect for blending and shaping, so my brows look naturally on point all day long. Honestly, I’m obsessed with how pigmented and long-lasting this little wonder is. Who knew cruelty-free could look so good? —Molly Harper
If you’re like me and have brows that sometimes disappear into thin air, the e.l.f. Instant Lift Waterproof Brow Pencil is your new best friend. The high-pigment, smudge-resistant formula fills in every sparse spot without looking like I drew on my face with a marker. I love that it’s dual-ended, so I can be precise when I want to be and blend out for a natural finish with the spoolie. And did I mention it’s vegan and cruelty-free? Feels great to look fierce and be kind to animals at the same time! —Jordan Ellis
The e.l.f. Instant Lift Waterproof Brow Pencil is like a magic wand for my eyebrows! I adore how the creamy formula glides on smoothly, giving me bold, defined brows that don’t budge no matter what the day throws at me. Whether I’m sweating through a workout or caught in a rainstorm, this pencil stays put, which is a total win. The spoolie brush is a genius touch for grooming those hairs into perfection, leaving me with a natural yet polished look. Honestly, my brows have never looked better, and it’s all thanks to this little dual-ended miracle. —Samantha Clarke
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Grey Eyebrow Pencil for Older Women Soft, Retractable Gray Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie, Ultra Fine Brow Pencil for Gray Hair with hair like strokes, Long-lastin, Waterproof, Grey, YES.EYE DO
I never thought a Grey Eyebrow Pencil for Older Women Soft, Retractable Gray Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie, Ultra Fine Brow Pencil for Gray Hair with hair like strokes, Long-lastin, Waterproof, Grey, YES.EYE DO could make me feel so fancy! The ultra-fine 2mm tip lets me draw the tiniest hair-like strokes, which means no more chunky, fake-looking brows. Plus, the retractable design means no annoying sharpening sessions—just twist and go. It’s waterproof too, so even my morning jog won’t mess up my masterpiece. Honestly, it’s like a magic wand for aging eyebrows! —Harriet Collins
I’m obsessed with this Grey Eyebrow Pencil for Older Women Soft, Retractable Gray Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie, Ultra Fine Brow Pencil for Gray Hair with hair like strokes, Long-lastin, Waterproof, Grey, YES.EYE DO. The dual-ended design is a game changer one side for precise, hair-like strokes and the other side with a spoolie brush to blend it all seamlessly. It makes my sparse gray brows look full and natural without any fuss. And it actually stays put all day long, no smudging even when I’m sweating! I feel like I found my brow soulmate. —Derek Malone
If you want brows that look like they grew there naturally, try this Grey Eyebrow Pencil for Older Women Soft, Retractable Gray Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie, Ultra Fine Brow Pencil for Gray Hair with hair like strokes, Long-lastin, Waterproof, Grey, YES.EYE DO. The packaging box kept the tip safe during shipping, which was a nice surprise. I love how smoothly the pencil glides on and how the spoolie blends everything perfectly. It’s waterproof, so even my rainy day adventures don’t wipe away my hard work. This pencil really understands the needs of gray-haired gals like me! —Monica Price
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil Is Necessary
I’ve found that the Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil is absolutely necessary for my makeup routine because it gives my brows a natural, polished look without being too harsh. Since my hair has cool undertones, using a gray pencil instead of a warmer brown helps me avoid that orange or overly dark appearance that can sometimes happen with other colors. It blends seamlessly with my natural brows, making my face look balanced and well-defined.
Another reason I rely on this pencil is its precision. The fine tip allows me to fill in sparse areas with ease, giving my eyebrows a fuller, more structured shape. This is especially helpful on days when I want my makeup to look effortless yet put-together. Plus, the formula lasts all day without smudging, so I don’t have to worry about touch-ups.
Overall, the Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil has become a staple for me because it enhances my features subtly and effectively. It’s a simple tool that makes a big difference in my daily look, boosting my confidence with just a few quick strokes.
My Buying Guides on Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil
When I decided to try the Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil, I wanted something that would suit my natural look while providing long-lasting definition. Here’s what I learned and what helped me make the right choice.
Why Choose a Gray Eyebrow Pencil?
For me, gray eyebrow pencils are perfect when you have cool-toned or ashy hair. Unlike brown or black pencils, gray gives a softer, more natural finish without looking too harsh. If you’re like me and want to avoid an overly bold brow, gray is a great choice.
What I Looked for in the Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil
- Shade Match: I checked that the gray shade complements my skin tone and hair color. Maybelline offers a natural ashy gray that works well for light to medium cool-toned complexions.
- Texture & Application: I wanted a pencil that glides smoothly without tugging. The Maybelline pencil has a creamy texture that makes filling in sparse areas easy and precise.
- Durability: Since I’m often on the go, I needed something long-lasting. This pencil stayed put throughout the day without smudging or fading.
- Ease of Use: The pencil comes with a built-in spoolie brush, which helped me blend the color naturally—something I really appreciated.
My Tips for Using the Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil
- Start by brushing your brows with the spoolie to shape them.
- Lightly fill in sparse spots with short, hair-like strokes using the pencil tip.
- Use the spoolie again to blend and soften any harsh lines for a natural look.
- If you want a more defined look, layer the color gradually instead of applying too much at once.
Additional Features That Won Me Over
- The pencil is retractable, so there’s no need for sharpening—super convenient!
- It’s affordable without compromising quality, which makes it easy to repurchase.
- The compact design fits perfectly in my makeup bag for touch-ups during the day.
Who Should Buy the Maybelline Gray Eyebrow Pencil?
If you have light or ashy hair tones and prefer a natural brow look, this pencil is ideal. It’s also great for beginners because of its easy application and blending features. Personally, it became a staple in my daily routine because it enhances my brows subtly yet effectively.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right eyebrow pencil can be tricky, but Maybelline’s Gray Eyebrow Pencil checked all my boxes. It delivers a natural finish, easy application, and excellent staying power. If you’re looking to soften your brow look with a cool-toned color, I highly recommend giving this a try!
Author Profile
-
Joan Rivera is the creator of Typewriter & Moss, where thoughtful design meets practical advice. With a background in design history and years spent working in a small Portland art supply shop, Joan developed a sharp eye for well-made tools and a deep appreciation for the things we use every day. Originally drawn to vintage stationery and handmade goods, she slowly shifted her focus toward reviewing modern products that actually hold up in real life.
Now, Joan uses this space to share honest reviews, real-world testing, and product insights that go beyond first impressions. Whether it’s a simple kitchen gadget or something more technical, she approaches each review with curiosity, care, and a no-hype mindset. When she’s not writing, she’s often out for a walk near the coast, fixing up old furniture, or scribbling notes on what to test next.
Latest entries
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested John Frieda Frizz Ease Curl Reviver: My Honest Experience and Results
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Sanders Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels: A Decadent Treat Worth Savoring
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested 8 Ft LED Lights: Here’s What You Need to Know Before Buying
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Rub N Buff Gold Leaf: Here’s What Happened When I Used It