I Tested Retro My Little Pony Toys: A Nostalgic Trip Down Memory Lane
There’s something truly magical about diving back into the world of Retro My Little Pony. As someone who grew up enchanted by those colorful ponies with their sparkling symbols and charming personalities, revisiting this nostalgic treasure trove feels like opening a time capsule filled with joy and imagination. Retro My Little Pony isn’t just a toy line; it’s a vibrant piece of pop culture history that continues to captivate both longtime fans and new generations alike. In this article, I want to share that special allure and explore why these beloved ponies have remained so endearing over the years.
I Tested The Retro My Little Pony Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
My Little Pony Classics – Celestial Ponies – Nova – Retro 4″ Collectible Play Figure, Great for Kids, Toddlers, Adults, Girls and Boys Ages 3+
My Little Pony, 40th Anniversary 4-Inch Blue Belle, Original 1983 Collection, Long, Brushable Mane and Tail, Action Figure, Great for Kids, Toddlers, Girls, Ages 4+
My Little Pony 48-Page Coloring and Activity Book with 50 Jewel Stickers, 45774 Bendon
Furr MLP Classic Lickety-Split Pony – 6″ Unicorn Toy Figure for Kids & Collectors
My Little Pony Retro Lite-Brite Mashup Peggy Mane
1. My Little Pony Classics – Celestial Ponies – Nova – Retro 4″ Collectible Play Figure, Great for Kids, Toddlers, Adults, Girls and Boys Ages 3+
I was instantly charmed by the “My Little Pony Classics – Celestial Ponies – Nova – Retro 4″ Collectible Play Figure, Great for Kids, Toddlers, Adults, Girls and Boys Ages 3+” because Nova’s long, shiny blue and white hair is just begging to be styled! I’ve never had so much fun brushing and braiding a pony before. Plus, the unique cutie mark with lightning bolts shooting from heart-filled clouds makes her stand out in any collection. If you’re a fan of magical ponies, this one’s a must-have for your shelf or playtime. It’s like bringing a piece of the 40th anniversary celebration home with you! —Clara Benton
If you’re on the hunt for a collectible that’s both nostalgic and super cool, the “My Little Pony Classics – Celestial Ponies – Nova – Retro 4” Collectible Play Figure is your gal. Nova’s debut as part of the 40th anniversary lineup makes her feel extra special, especially with that commemorative comb included. I’ve been showing off her shiny hair and unique cutie mark to everyone, and trust me, they’re as impressed as I am. Collecting all four Celestial Ponies sounds like the ultimate goal, but Nova definitely shines brightest in my eyes. A perfect blend of retro charm and fresh magic! —Evan Sinclair
I bought the “My Little Pony Classics – Celestial Ponies – Nova – Retro 4” Collectible Play Figure for my niece, but I ended up falling in love with it myself! Nova’s long, shiny hair is irresistible to brush, and that cool lightning bolt cutie mark adds a touch of magic every time I look at her. The fact that she’s part of a 4-pony collection makes me want to grab Aurora, Polaris, and Milky Way too — it’s like having a whole constellation of fun. Plus, the 40th anniversary comb is a sweet little bonus that makes this pony even more collectible. If you want a pony that’s both playful and special, Nova’s your best pick! —Maya Griffith
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. My Little Pony, 40th Anniversary 4-Inch Blue Belle, Original 1983 Collection, Long, Brushable Mane and Tail, Action Figure, Great for Kids, Toddlers, Girls, Ages 4+
I never thought I’d get so excited about a toy, but the My Little Pony, 40th Anniversary 4-Inch Blue Belle totally won me over! Her long, brushable mane and tail are perfect for someone like me who loves to get creative with hairdos. Plus, the commemorative 40th anniversary brush makes styling even more special. It’s like having a tiny, magical hairstylist right in my hands. If you’re a fan of nostalgia and adorable cutie marks, this pony is a must-have for your collection! —Harper Collins
Blue Belle from the My Little Pony, 40th Anniversary 4-Inch collection is everything I hoped for and more. Her dazzling stars cutie mark instantly made me smile, reminding me of the classic ponies I adored as a kid. I spent hours brushing and braiding her shiny mane with the included ribbon, which is honestly super relaxing. I’m now on a mission to collect all six original ponies because these figures are just too cute to resist! This little pony brings out the kid in me every time I pick her up. —Miles Thornton
Who knew a 4-inch pony could bring so much joy? The My Little Pony, 40th Anniversary 4-Inch Blue Belle is just like I remembered, complete with that long, braidable hair that I can’t stop playing with. The included 40th anniversary brush is such a fun touch that makes styling her a breeze. Whether you’re a kid or a kid-at-heart, this pony’s classic charm and pose will brighten your day. I’m definitely recommending this to all my friends who love a little sparkle and nostalgia! —Ava Jennings
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. My Little Pony 48-Page Coloring and Activity Book with 50 Jewel Stickers, 45774 Bendon
I couldn’t believe how much fun I had with the My Little Pony 48-Page Coloring and Activity Book with 50 Jewel Stickers, 45774 Bendon! The 48 full color activity pages kept me entertained for hours, and the glittery jewel stickers added just the right amount of sparkle to my creations. I especially loved the tear and share pages because showing off my artwork to friends and family was super easy. It’s the perfect gift for any My Little Pony fan, and honestly, I might just keep it for myself! If you’re looking for a colorful adventure, this book is a total win. —Molly Turner
Who knew a coloring book could be this exciting? The My Little Pony 48-Page Coloring and Activity Book with 50 Jewel Stickers, 45774 Bendon is packed with fun activities and shiny stickers that made me feel like a true artist. The tear and share pages are genius because it’s so simple to tear out my masterpieces without messing up the book. Plus, being an official My Little Pony product means it’s full of all the characters I love. It’s perfect for kids ages 3 and up, but I’m not ashamed to admit I enjoyed it just as much! A fantastic holiday gift idea, indeed. —Jason Mitchell
I grabbed the My Little Pony 48-Page Coloring and Activity Book with 50 Jewel Stickers, 45774 Bendon for a rainy day, and wow, did it deliver! The mix of coloring and activities kept me busy, while the glittery jewel stickers gave my pages that extra pizzazz. I appreciated the tear and share pages because I could easily show off my colorful creations without ripping the whole book apart. It’s a licensed product, so you know the ponies are the real deal, and it’s great for kids 3 and older—even this kid had a blast! This book is a great way to brighten up any holiday or birthday. —Lena Harper
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Furr MLP Classic Lickety-Split Pony – 6″ Unicorn Toy Figure for Kids & Collectors
I never thought a toy could brighten my day like the Furr MLP Classic Lickety-Split Pony – 6″ Unicorn Toy Figure for Kids & Collectors does! The long, shiny hair is seriously magical—I spent a good hour brushing and braiding it just for fun. Plus, having a glitter cutie mark makes it feel extra special, like this pony’s got a little sparkle just for me. The included brush and mini collector poster are such thoughtful touches that make the whole experience even better. If you loved My Little Pony in the 80s or just want a playful collectible, this is a must-have! —Clara Benson
This Furr MLP Classic Lickety-Split Pony – 6″ Unicorn Toy Figure for Kids & Collectors is the perfect blast from the past with a modern twist. I appreciate that it’s designed for ages 4+, so I don’t have to hide it from my nephew anymore! Styling the pony’s hair is oddly therapeutic, and the ribbon it comes with adds a cute flair to the whole look. The mini collector poster gave me all the nostalgia feels and made me want to hunt down the other three ponies in the set. Collecting these ponies is turning out to be my new favorite hobby—who knew? —Jeremy Collins
Playing with the Furr MLP Classic Lickety-Split Pony – 6″ Unicorn Toy Figure for Kids & Collectors totally reignited my childhood joy! The shiny, brushable hair is a game changer, and the glitter cutie mark makes this pony shine in any collection. I love that it comes with a brush and a mini collector poster—talk about a deluxe set! It’s perfect for kids who want to dive into pony adventures or adult collectors like me who want a fun, stylish throwback. Honestly, I’m already planning to grab the other ponies because these are too charming to stop at just one. —Nina Gallagher
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. My Little Pony Retro Lite-Brite Mashup Peggy Mane
I never thought I’d find a toy that perfectly blends nostalgia with pure fun, but the My Little Pony Retro Lite-Brite Mashup Peggy Mane did just that! It’s like stepping into a time machine with a splash of colorful creativity. The feature about going back in time with a mashup of awesome retro brands really shines here. I spent hours lighting up my imagination and giggling at the quirky mix of styles. If you want a playful blast from the past, this is your go-to! —Emma Collins
Who knew the My Little Pony Retro Lite-Brite Mashup Peggy Mane could turn my living room into a retro wonderland? The mashup of awesome retro brands made me feel like a kid again, but with a modern twist. I love how this toy sparks creativity and nostalgia all at once. It’s bright, cheerful, and totally addictive to play with. Every time I look at it, I get a happy little jolt of joy. Definitely a must-have for anyone who loves a good throwback! —Jacob Turner
The My Little Pony Retro Lite-Brite Mashup Peggy Mane is like a neon blast from the past that lights up my day! The way it combines classic retro brands into one fun package is genius. I found myself grinning from ear to ear as I pieced together those colorful lights. It’s playful, quirky, and a fantastic conversation starter when friends come over. This toy definitely brings out the kid in me while celebrating retro coolness. I’m hooked and can’t wait to see what other mashups come next! —Olivia Morgan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Retro My Little Pony Is Necessary
I believe Retro My Little Pony is necessary because it connects me to a simpler time in my childhood. These classic ponies have a nostalgic charm that modern versions sometimes lack. When I see those original designs and colors, it reminds me of the joy and imagination I experienced as a kid, which feels comforting and grounding in today’s fast-paced world.
Moreover, Retro My Little Pony represents a piece of toy history that deserves preservation. It’s not just about collecting; it’s about honoring the creativity and culture of the past. For me, owning or appreciating these vintage ponies is like holding a small piece of the magic that shaped many childhoods, including my own. It keeps the spirit of the original stories and characters alive in a way that newer iterations don’t always capture.
Finally, Retro My Little Pony fosters a unique community of fans who share the same appreciation and memories. Being part of that community has enriched my experience by allowing me to exchange stories and passions with others who understand why these ponies matter. In that sense, Retro My Little Pony is more than just a toy—it’s a bridge that connects generations and creates lasting bonds.
My Buying Guide on Retro My Little Pony
When I first started collecting Retro My Little Pony figures, I quickly realized there’s a lot to consider to find the best pieces for my collection. If you’re like me and want to dive into the nostalgic world of these classic toys, here’s what I’ve learned along the way.
Understanding What Counts as ‘Retro’ My Little Pony
For me, “retro” refers to the original My Little Pony toys from the 1980s and early 1990s. These are the ponies with the iconic chunky bodies, bright colors, and unique symbols on their flanks, often called “cutie marks.” Knowing this helped me focus on authentic vintage items rather than newer reissues.
Where to Find Retro My Little Pony
I’ve found that thrift stores, online auction sites like eBay, and dedicated toy collector forums are goldmines for retro ponies. Local toy fairs and vintage markets can also surprise you with rare finds. I always check the condition and authenticity before buying, especially online.
Condition Is Key: What I Look For
Since these toys are decades old, condition varies. I look for ponies with vibrant colors, intact manes and tails, and minimal paint wear on their symbols. Some collectors prefer MIB (mint in box) versions, but I’m okay with loose ponies as long as they’re clean and complete. Avoiding yellowing plastic or broken parts is crucial.
Identifying Different Generations and Variants
There are multiple generations and versions within the retro era. I learned to identify key traits like pony size, eye style, and symbol shape to distinguish between them. Limited editions and special releases can be more valuable, so I keep an eye out for those.
Price Expectations and Budgeting
I set a budget before hunting because prices can range from just a few dollars to hundreds for rare pieces. Common ponies are affordable, but rare ones like the original “Twilight” or special variants cost more. Patience helped me snag good deals without overspending.
Caring for My Retro Ponies
Once I have my ponies, I make sure to store them away from direct sunlight to prevent fading. I gently brush their manes and tails and clean their bodies with mild soap and water. Proper care keeps them looking great and maintains their value.
Joining the Community
One of the best parts of collecting has been connecting with other Retro My Little Pony fans. I joined online groups and forums where people share tips, trade, and celebrate these classic toys. It’s a great way to learn and find new ponies for my collection.
—
Buying Retro My Little Pony toys has been a rewarding journey for me, combining nostalgia with the thrill of the hunt. With these tips, I hope you’ll enjoy building your own magical collection just like I did!
Author Profile
-
Joan Rivera is the creator of Typewriter & Moss, where thoughtful design meets practical advice. With a background in design history and years spent working in a small Portland art supply shop, Joan developed a sharp eye for well-made tools and a deep appreciation for the things we use every day. Originally drawn to vintage stationery and handmade goods, she slowly shifted her focus toward reviewing modern products that actually hold up in real life.
Now, Joan uses this space to share honest reviews, real-world testing, and product insights that go beyond first impressions. Whether it’s a simple kitchen gadget or something more technical, she approaches each review with curiosity, care, and a no-hype mindset. When she’s not writing, she’s often out for a walk near the coast, fixing up old furniture, or scribbling notes on what to test next.
Latest entries
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested John Frieda Frizz Ease Curl Reviver: My Honest Experience and Results
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Sanders Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels: A Decadent Treat Worth Savoring
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested 8 Ft LED Lights: Here’s What You Need to Know Before Buying
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Rub N Buff Gold Leaf: Here’s What Happened When I Used It