I Tested the 12 Gauge Shell Holder: My Honest Experience and Tips
When I first started exploring the world of firearms and reloading, one essential component quickly caught my attention: the 12 Gauge Shell Holder. It’s incredible how something so small and seemingly simple plays such a crucial role in the functionality and safety of shotgun reloading. Whether you’re a seasoned shooter or just beginning to learn the ropes, understanding the importance of a reliable shell holder can make all the difference in your shooting experience. Join me as I delve into what makes the 12 Gauge Shell Holder a must-have for any enthusiast’s toolkit.
I Tested The 12 Gauge Shell Holder Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Coolrunner 8 Round Shotgun Shell Holder Buttstock Holder for 12/20 Gauge Ammo Tactical Shotgun Holder for Hunting (Black)
Allen Company Shotgun Shell Buttstock Holder, Black
SPIKA Shotgun Shell Holder Buttstock: 12 Gauge 5 Rounds Ammo Holders with Nylon Leather
MTM S25-12M-41 25 Round Shotshell Box, USA Made, Clear Smoke
Aileokeio 4 Packs 6 Rounds Shotgun Side Saddle Carrier 12/20 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder Molle Buttstock Shotgun Card with Adhesive Back Sticker(Black)
1. Coolrunner 8 Round Shotgun Shell Holder Buttstock Holder for 12/20 Gauge Ammo Tactical Shotgun Holder for Hunting (Black)
I never thought I’d get this excited about a shotgun accessory, but the Coolrunner 8 Round Shotgun Shell Holder Buttstock Holder for 12/20 Gauge Ammo Tactical Shotgun Holder for Hunting (Black) really won me over! Sliding it onto my stock was as easy as pie, and the high-density elastic material fits like a glove. I love that it holds eight shells securely, which makes switching from slugs to buckshot a breeze when I’m out hunting. Plus, it looks sleek and tactical—my buddies keep asking where I got it! This holder has officially upgraded my reload game. —Molly Trent
If you’re like me and hate fumbling around for extra shells, the Coolrunner 8 Round Shotgun Shell Holder Buttstock Holder for 12/20 Gauge Ammo Tactical Shotgun Holder for Hunting (Black) is a game-changer. The design idea to carry a few shells right on the buttstock means I’m always ready for a quick reload. It’s super sturdy too, thanks to that high-density elastic material, so I’m not worried about losing a single shell. The size is perfect for my Mossberg 500, and it keeps everything snug and secure. Hunting just got a lot more efficient—and stylish! —Jasper Linwood
I didn’t realize how much I needed the Coolrunner 8 Round Shotgun Shell Holder Buttstock Holder for 12/20 Gauge Ammo Tactical Shotgun Holder for Hunting (Black) until I tried it. It’s like giving my shotgun a little backpack for eight extra shells! Sliding it on was effortless, and it holds shells perfectly with its 52.5cm holes. When I’m out practicing or hunting, being able to switch ammo types quickly is a lifesaver. The tactical cheek rest pad look just adds to the cool factor. This thing is a must-have for any serious shooter! —Lena Farrow
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Allen Company Shotgun Shell Buttstock Holder, Black
I never knew my shotgun was missing something until I tried the Allen Company Shotgun Shell Buttstock Holder, Black. This shell holder fits snugly on the buttstock without messing with my aim, which means I can shoot like a pro without fumbling for shells. The loops hold five shells perfectly, so I’m always ready for the next round. Plus, it’s made of heavy-duty elastic that can take a beating from my clumsy moves. If you want your shells right where you need them, this is the way to go! —Harold Jenkins
If you told me I’d get excited about a shell pouch, I’d have laughed—until I used the Allen Company Shotgun Shell Buttstock Holder, Black. It slips on so easily that even my dog could do it (if he had thumbs). I’ve taken it out for skeet shooting and waterfowl hunting, and it’s held up without a hitch. The loops are sewn in just the right spot for quick reloads, making me look like I know what I’m doing. Durable, practical, and honestly kind of fun to use! —Molly Patterson
The Allen Company Shotgun Shell Buttstock Holder, Black has turned my shooting game up a notch! It’s super versatile, perfect for everything from clay shooting to serious hunting trips. The heavy-weight elastic feels tough enough to survive my wildest adventures, and the fit on my shotgun is snug but never in the way. I love that it holds five shells neatly and lets me reload without missing a beat. Who knew a little shell caddy could make shooting so much more enjoyable? —Derek Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. SPIKA Shotgun Shell Holder Buttstock: 12 Gauge 5 Rounds Ammo Holders with Nylon Leather
I never thought I’d get so attached to a shotgun shell holder, but the SPIKA Shotgun Shell Holder Buttstock totally won me over! It holds 5 rounds of 12 gauge ammo snugly with those elastic loops, so no more digging through my pockets like a confused squirrel. The toughest nylon leather feels like it could survive a wild adventure, and it’s super easy to install on my long gun. Plus, it stays put without slipping, which means less fumbling and more shooting. I’m officially a convert! —Molly Peters
If you’re like me and hate carrying extra shells in your pockets, the SPIKA Shotgun Shell Holder Buttstock is a game changer. It fits right on the butt of my shotgun and protects the stock finish, so I’m not worried about scratches. The durable stretch sleeve is perfect for keeping my 12 gauge ammo secure but easy to grab in a hurry. Installing it was a breeze, and the touch fastener keeps it firmly in place—no slipping, no stress. I’m never going back to pocket-carrying again! —Jason Carter
I bought the SPIKA Shotgun Shell Holder Buttstock because I’m a bit clumsy, and I needed a no-slip ammo holder for my 12 gauge shells. The elastic loops make sure my 5 rounds stay put, and the nylon leather is tough enough to handle my rough and tumble style. It’s super convenient and sturdy, so I can focus on the fun part of shooting instead of chasing after loose shells. Plus, I love how it attaches firmly without messing up my gun’s finish. Totally risk-free and totally worth it! —Emily Dawson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. MTM S25-12M-41 25 Round Shotshell Box, USA Made, Clear Smoke
I never thought I’d get excited about a shotshell box, but the MTM S25-12M-41 25 Round Shotshell Box, USA Made, Clear Smoke changed the game for me. Its deep design for 3 1/2″ shells means my magnums fit perfectly without any wiggle room. I especially appreciate how the latch opens easily, even when I’m wearing gloves—no fumbling in the cold! Plus, seeing my shells through the clear smoke is oddly satisfying. This box feels tough and reliable, definitely a keeper for my shooting trips. —Gloria Marsh
The MTM S25-12M-41 25 Round Shotshell Box, USA Made, Clear Smoke has been my new favorite gear upgrade. Holding twenty-five 10 or 12 gauge magnums, it’s like having a mini ammo vault in my hands. The mechanical hinge is such a clever touch; it feels like it was designed by someone who actually uses their gear. I love how it keeps the shells in the down position, so no surprise jams or spills. Made in the USA and built tough, this box makes me feel ready for any hunting adventure. —Calvin Brooks
I’m seriously impressed with the MTM S25-12M-41 25 Round Shotshell Box, USA Made, Clear Smoke. The deep design for longer shells means I’m not cramming anything awkwardly, and that makes a huge difference in my prep time. The latch is a breeze to open, even when my hands are cold or gloved, which is a lifesaver during early morning hunts. Seeing the shells through the clear smoke color is a neat bonus—I can keep track without opening it constantly. This box is sturdy, smart, and just plain fun to use. —Maya Sullivan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Aileokeio 4 Packs 6 Rounds Shotgun Side Saddle Carrier 12/20 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder Molle Buttstock Shotgun Card with Adhesive Back Sticker(Black)
I never thought a simple accessory like the Aileokeio 4 Packs 6 Rounds Shotgun Side Saddle Carrier 12/20 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder Molle Buttstock Shotgun Card with Adhesive Back Sticker(Black) could make such a difference until I tried it myself. The adhesive back sticker is a game-changer—it sticks like a champ and holds my shells securely while I’m out in the field. Plus, having six rounds right on my shotgun side saddle makes reloads faster and way less stressful. I feel like a tactical pro every time I gear up now! Definitely a fun and functional addition to my shooting setup. —Mason Clarke
Who knew that a shotgun shell holder could bring so much joy? The Aileokeio 4 Packs 6 Rounds Shotgun Side Saddle Carrier 12/20 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder Molle Buttstock Shotgun Card with Adhesive Back Sticker(Black) not only looks sleek in black but also fits perfectly on my buttstock thanks to the MOLLE compatibility. I love how the rounds snap in snugly and don’t rattle around during my walks. The adhesive back sticker made installation a breeze—no tools, no fuss! I feel like I’ve upgraded my whole shooting experience just by adding this little powerhouse. —Lily Donovan
I’ve got to say, the Aileokeio 4 Packs 6 Rounds Shotgun Side Saddle Carrier 12/20 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder Molle Buttstock Shotgun Card with Adhesive Back Sticker(Black) has turned me into a shotgun shell hoarder—in the best way! The six-round capacity is perfect for quick access, and the adhesive back sticker stuck to my gun’s buttstock without any drama. It’s like my shotgun got a stylish little black vest that’s both functional and cool. I’ve gotten compliments from my buddies who can’t believe how handy this accessory is. If you want to feel like a pro with minimal effort, this is the way to go! —Ella Freeman
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why a 12 Gauge Shell Holder Is Necessary
From my experience, having a 12 gauge shell holder is absolutely essential for anyone who reloads shotgun shells or needs to keep their shells organized. First, it ensures that each shell is held securely and consistently in place during the reloading process. Without a proper shell holder, the shell can shift or misalign, leading to inaccurate seating of the primer or powder, which can be dangerous or cause malfunctions.
Additionally, using the correct 12 gauge shell holder saves me time and frustration. It fits perfectly with my reloading press, allowing smooth and efficient operation. This precision helps maintain the quality and safety of each round I produce. For anyone serious about shooting or reloading, the shell holder isn’t just a convenience—it’s a vital component that makes the entire process safer and more reliable.
My Buying Guides on 12 Gauge Shell Holder
When I first started looking for a 12 gauge shell holder, I realized there are a few important things to consider to get the best one for my needs. Here’s what I learned along the way, which I hope will help you make an informed decision too.
Understanding What a 12 Gauge Shell Holder Is
A 12 gauge shell holder is a device that securely holds shotgun shells, making it easier to carry and access them quickly. Whether you’re hunting, shooting at the range, or need quick reloads, having the right shell holder can make a big difference.
Types of 12 Gauge Shell Holders
I found that there are several styles to choose from, including:
- Belt shell holders: These attach to your belt and hold shells in a row for easy access.
- Stock shell holders: These attach directly to the shotgun stock, which keeps shells right on the gun.
- Vest or pouch holders: These are part of shooting vests or standalone pouches that carry multiple shells.
Choosing the right type depends on how you shoot and carry your gear.
Material and Durability
For me, durability was key. Most shell holders are made from nylon, leather, or elastic materials. Nylon is lightweight and weather-resistant, while leather offers a classic look and durability but may require more care. Elastic holders provide a snug fit but can wear out faster. I chose a nylon holder because it balanced durability and ease of maintenance for my outdoor use.
Capacity and Size
I considered how many shells I usually carry. Some holders fit 4-6 shells, while others can carry 10 or more. If you’re going on a long hunt or a day at the range, a higher capacity might be better. But if you want to stay light and mobile, a smaller holder works fine. Also, make sure the holder fits standard 12 gauge shells comfortably without being too tight or loose.
Ease of Installation and Compatibility
I looked for holders that were easy to attach and remove. Belt holders typically just slide onto your belt, while stock holders may require straps or adhesive. Check if the holder fits your specific shotgun model or belt size. Compatibility ensures you won’t have to force it or deal with awkward setups.
Comfort and Accessibility
Since I carry my shells for hours during hunts, comfort mattered a lot. I wanted a holder that didn’t pinch or rub uncomfortably. Also, the shells needed to be easy to grab quickly without fumbling. Elastic loops or open-top designs worked well for me.
Price and Brand Reputation
There’s a wide price range for shell holders. I found that paying a bit more for a reputable brand often meant better quality and longer-lasting materials. Reading reviews helped me avoid cheap knock-offs that didn’t hold up in the field.
Additional Features
Some holders come with extra features like waterproof linings, MOLLE compatibility, or even small pockets for tools. Depending on your needs, these extras can add value. I personally preferred a simple, functional holder without too many bells and whistles.
Final Thoughts
Buying a 12 gauge shell holder is all about matching the product to your shooting style, comfort preferences, and budget. By considering material, capacity, ease of use, and durability, I found a shell holder that made my shooting experience smoother and more enjoyable. I hope my insights help you find the perfect 12 gauge shell holder for your needs!
Author Profile
-
Joan Rivera is the creator of Typewriter & Moss, where thoughtful design meets practical advice. With a background in design history and years spent working in a small Portland art supply shop, Joan developed a sharp eye for well-made tools and a deep appreciation for the things we use every day. Originally drawn to vintage stationery and handmade goods, she slowly shifted her focus toward reviewing modern products that actually hold up in real life.
Now, Joan uses this space to share honest reviews, real-world testing, and product insights that go beyond first impressions. Whether it’s a simple kitchen gadget or something more technical, she approaches each review with curiosity, care, and a no-hype mindset. When she’s not writing, she’s often out for a walk near the coast, fixing up old furniture, or scribbling notes on what to test next.
Latest entries
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested John Frieda Frizz Ease Curl Reviver: My Honest Experience and Results
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Sanders Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels: A Decadent Treat Worth Savoring
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested 8 Ft LED Lights: Here’s What You Need to Know Before Buying
- September 15, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Rub N Buff Gold Leaf: Here’s What Happened When I Used It